.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
Clawback Provisions
Clawback provisions, often found in executive compensation agreements or incentive plans, are contractual clauses that allow a company to recover previously disbursed compensation or benefits under certain circumstances.
What are clawback provisions?
Clawback provisions, often found in contracts or agreements, are clauses that enable a party to reclaim previously disbursed compensation or benefits under specific circumstances. These provisions are designed to address situations where the recipient of compensation engages in conduct that is detrimental to the interests of the party providing the compensation.
Clawback provisions can be implemented in various contexts, including executive compensation agreements, incentive plans, investment contracts, and employment agreements.
What is an example of a clawback provision?
A common clawback provision example is found in executive compensation agreements. Suppose a CEO receives a $500,000 performance bonus based on the company’s annual revenue.
Later, the revenue is restated due to accounting errors, revealing the performance target was not actually met. Under the claw back provision, the company can demand the return of that bonus, either in part or in full.
This kind of clawback provision protects companies from rewarding inflated or inaccurate results and is especially prevalent in publicly traded firms.
What is the clawback provision in an LPA?
In a Limited Partnership Agreement (LPA), a clawback provision ensures that general partners (GPs) do not receive more than their entitled share of profits over the fund’s life.
For example, if a GP receives carried interest early in the fund’s life based on initial gains, but subsequent investments underperform, the clawback provision requires the GP to return the excess amount to limited partners (LPs).
This protects LPs and ensures a fair distribution of profits, maintaining the integrity of private equity or venture capital arrangements.
Are clawback provisions legal in all states?
Clawback provisions are generally enforceable across most U.S. states, but their legality can depend on how they are drafted and the specific employment laws of the state. While federal laws like the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and Dodd-Frank Act mandate clawback provisions in certain public company scenarios, state-level enforceability may hinge on:
- Contract clarity and mutual agreement
- State labor laws on wage deductions
- Timelines and triggers for the clawback
Some states may have stricter rules about deducting wages already paid, especially for rank-and-file employees, so legal review is recommended before enforcement.
Can clawback provisions apply to stock options or RSUs?
Yes, clawback provisions can apply to stock options and Restricted Stock Units (RSUs). These equity-based incentives often come with performance or service conditions. If an employee leaves under disqualifying circumstances—such as misconduct—or if the performance metrics tied to the awards are later found to be inaccurate, the employer can invoke a claw back provision to reclaim the value of those equity grants.
This is especially common in executive compensation plans to ensure alignment with long-term shareholder value and regulatory compliance.
Why are clawback provisions important?
Clawback provisions help maintain ethical standards and financial accuracy within a company. They are especially crucial in cases involving bonuses, stock options, or incentives where performance results are later found to be inaccurate or fraudulent. This provision builds trust among stakeholders by reinforcing responsibility and discouraging unethical behavior.
When is a clawback provision enforced?
Companies usually enforce claw back provisions after discovering:
- Financial misstatements
- Breaches of conduct or fiduciary duty
- Regulatory violations
- Failure to meet long-term performance goals
It typically comes into play post-payment, often months or even years after the initial compensation was issued.
Enquêtes sur le pouls des employés :
Il s'agit d'enquêtes courtes qui peuvent être envoyées fréquemment pour vérifier rapidement ce que vos employés pensent d'un sujet. L'enquête comprend moins de questions (pas plus de 10) afin d'obtenir rapidement des informations. Elles peuvent être administrées à intervalles réguliers (mensuels/hebdomadaires/trimestriels).
Rencontres individuelles :
Organiser périodiquement des réunions d'une heure pour discuter de manière informelle avec chaque membre de l'équipe est un excellent moyen de se faire une idée précise de ce qui se passe avec eux. Comme il s'agit d'une conversation sûre et privée, elle vous permet d'obtenir de meilleurs détails sur un problème.
eNPS :
L'eNPS (employee Net Promoter score) est l'un des moyens les plus simples et les plus efficaces d'évaluer l'opinion de vos employés sur votre entreprise. Il comprend une question intrigante qui permet d'évaluer la loyauté. Voici un exemple de questions posées dans le cadre de l'eNPS Quelle est la probabilité que vous recommandiez notre entreprise à d'autres personnes ? Les employés répondent à l'enquête eNPS sur une échelle de 1 à 10, où 10 signifie qu'ils sont "très susceptibles" de recommander l'entreprise et 1 signifie qu'ils sont "très peu susceptibles" de la recommander.
Sur la base des réponses, les salariés peuvent être classés dans trois catégories différentes :
- Promoteurs
Employés qui ont répondu positivement ou qui sont d'accord. - Détracteurs
Employés qui ont réagi négativement ou qui ont exprimé leur désaccord. - Passives
Les employés qui sont restés neutres dans leurs réponses.
How does a clawback provision work?
A clawback provision is triggered based on predefined terms in a contract. Once the triggering event (like accounting fraud or performance shortfall) occurs:
- The company identifies the compensation to be recovered.
- A formal request or legal notice is sent to the employee or beneficiary.
- The amount may be repaid voluntarily or deducted from future payments.
Legal enforceability may vary by jurisdiction and contract wording.
